confined to a single bulletin board in
an online community, netizens investigation teams exercise their influence within and across online communities. They also played a role in
calling out Choi Soon-sil’s corruption. The value of such investigative
experience is recognized for achieving future goals and developing self-efficacy. 3 Since self-efficacy is a crucial ingredient in many user behaviors
with ICT, it helps encourage netizens
to persevere toward their goal of
spreading the word. In another article, by Her, 10 their part in helping expose the scandal was described like
this: “In October [2016], they [neti-zens investigation teams] uncovered
a post by Choi Soon-sil’s daughter,
Jung Yoo-La, on her personal web-page, saying, ‘If you do not have the
ability, you blame your parents. Money is also an ability.’”
Public interest. Interest is a crucial
factor in citizen-led e-participation.
The example of Korean citizens communicating directly with members
of the National Assembly concerning perjury by the President’s chief
of staff was also related to a political
corruption scandal involving President Park Geun-hye and other important political and business figures. It
attracted significant public interest,
not only because of related headlines
in the country’s major newspapers
but also because it had become a
topic of everyday conversation in online communities and private group-chats via SMS, as well as in face-to-face everyday neighbor-to-neighbor
conversation. It was almost necessary
to be aware of the case just to be able
to engage in conversation with one’s
neighbors. The implication was and
still is that social interaction, a strong
theme behind millennial engagement, helped keep the public’s attention focused on the issue. The public’s desire for justice and displays of
patriotism was significant. The public’s antipathy toward the president’s
behavior thus accumulated until she
was finally impeached, with citizens
asking, “Is this a nation?” and wanting action on behalf of the country.
Kim Gwi-Ok, a professor of sociology
at Hansung University, explained it
like this: “Citizens who are tired of
politics and prosecutors have begun
more revealing, as it displayed wheth-
er a message had been delivered to
and read by its intended recipient(s).
Moreover, citizens could provide in-
formation to politicians and receive
feedback in real time. Being able to
reach members of the National As-
sembly in real time, personally and
directly, citizens could overcome the
shortcomings of traditional indirect
democracy. Various citizens said, “It
is a direct complaint,” “It is crazy that
online representative democracy is
just realized,” and “This is a revolu-
tion of direct democracy.” One mem-
ber of the Assembly, Park Young-sun,
communicated with citizens, not just
with her political aides, thus making
the communication direct.
Collective intelligence. Although an
individual citizen’s participation may
seem solitary, the wisdom of collective intelligence was now being exercised behind the scenes. On the informant’s first post revealing evidence
of Kim’s alleged perjury, he asked for
ways to alert the members of the Assembly about it, resulting in 98 comments of support and collaboration.
In the comments, citizens shared not
only the personal cellphone numbers of Assembly members but also
effective ways to ensure the evidence
would be included in subsequent
hearings. To attract even more citizen
participation, they joined him by “
liking” the post, helping push it to the
top of the board and leaving the comment: “Make this post to the top.”
Having observed the whole process
behind an historic alert by a citizen,
another citizen said, “Collective intelligence made it happen.” Online communities enable this mechanism and
process of collective intelligence. Yu27
wrote, “It is a combination of IT information network and collective intelligence of [the online community’s]
netizens.”
Prior experience in similar practice.
Some citizens were already aware of
the powerful effect collective intelligence can have. Looking to get down
to the as-yet-unspoken truth of a hot
political issue, they are sometimes
described collectively as “netizens investigation teams.” Unlike our focused context, where a single netizen
plays a key role in a real political moment and where the discussion is
Public disclosure
of Kim Ki-choon’s
alleged perjury
was led not by
the government
but by ordinary
citizens through
social media.